Food for thought

Where has the meat on your plate come from?

Submitted 13/02/2008 By BelindaE Views 4516 Comments 25 Updated 2/09/2008


Photographer : Az @ flickr


We are a compassionate species; we call the Wildlife Warriors when there’s a wallaby stuck in a fence, we cringe at the sight of road-kill, we even adopt dogs and cats as our life long companions. Animals have always been by our side—as our best friends and our helpers. So why do the majority of us make the conscious choice to eat animals? Where is the line drawn?

According to RSPCA Australia, the average Australian consumes around 107 kilograms of meat a year, which amounts to almost 500 million animals in total. That’s an easy enough sentence to read, but consider the emotional stress and physical pain those individual animals endure, and that sentence becomes a lot harder to swallow, so to speak.

To clear up anything your parents may have told you, the meat on your plate didn’t die of natural causes and chances are it didn’t live a happy life. The majority of animals raised for meat spend their lives in factory ‘farms’—huge, filthy warehouses. The animals are so tightly populated in these factories that they barely have enough room to turn around. For example, mothering pigs are debilitated in crates and stalls scarcely larger than their bodies. Many animals are pumped with drugs and hormones aimed at increasing growth and productivity. However, this often leads to crippling deformities and Sudden Death Syndrome because the animals’ limbs and vital organs cannot keep up.

Research conducted by People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA), has shown that animals are sometimes abused, pushed, thrown and taunted by workers. They suffer from unimaginable cruelty—cruelty that, if inflicted on a dog or cat, would be illegal. The animal welfare laws in Australia are in place to avoid the unnecessary suffering of factory farmed animals. However, according to Australian Government legislation, castrating, tail docking and beak removal without anaesthetic does not entail pain; over populating animals in filthy warehouses and denying them their natural habitat or normal social behaviour does not entail suffering. The laws that are in place often conflict with codes of practice and often not even properly enforced. This means the animals farmed for their flesh aren’t protected against severe harm, because we humans, in all our superiority, tend to ignore what we know isn’t right, as long as it’s practical for us.

At slaughter, many animals are still conscious while they have their throats slit, or are submerged in scalding water to remove feathers and hair. Some life huh? And this is only skimming the surface of the issue.

If that’s not reason enough to stop consuming meat products, think of your health. Leading health experts, such as the Sanitarium Health Food Company, have advised that switching to a well-balanced plant-based diet is the best thing you can do for your body. Research shows that cutting meat from your diet reduces the risk of acquiring several forms of cancer, obesity, diabetes, osteoporosis, asthma, male impotence, and improves the immune system. If that’s not enough, vegetarians and vegans live, on average, six to ten years longer than meat eaters! Common misconceptions that a plant-based diet deprives people of important vitamins and nutrients, such as iron and protein, are based on old, misleading research and are fuelled by strategic and expensive marketing campaigns by meat producers. A well-balanced vegetarian diet provides all the necessary vitamins and minerals needed, even for children.

As more and more research emerges advocating the benefits of a diet without meat, major meat producers, such as Meat and Livestock Australia (MLA) are creating campaigns in support of meat consumption. The book ‘Well Red’, produced by MLA, presents one-sided evidence in a seemingly desperate attempt to win back those questioning the effects of meat. It even labels red meat as ‘Mankind’s first Multivitamin’.

Another frustrating aspect of ‘Well Red’ is the claim that ‘work is underway to develop strategies to reduce the environmental impact of meat production.’ But none of the potential strategies are listed. At a time when everyone is turning off switches, reducing miles and recycling milk bottles, the single most effective way to reduce an individual’s greenhouse gas emissions is being ignored—stop eating meat. According to the National Greenhouse Gas Inventory Analysis, in 2005 livestock was accountable for 62.1 mega tons of greenhouse gas emissions in Australia. Compare this to the 70.67 megatons of carbon emitted from road transport. It’s scary that what goes on your plate has such a far-reaching impact.

If this worries you, you can make a difference. The evidence is out there to help you make an informed decision. There are endless Australian and international sites with further information on the meat industry, as well as overwhelming support to help you go vegetarian. The ethical, environmental and health impacts of animal consumption do not compare with the well-being of your taste-buds. Join some of history’s most influential people; Leonardo da Vinci, Thomas Edison, Albert Einstein, Pythagoras and Benjamin Franklin, among many others, were all vegetarians. Now that’s food for thought.

For more information:
1. www.animalsaustralia.org
2. www.animalliberation.org.au
3. www.goveg.org
4. www.peta.org
5. www.mla.com.au
6. www.rspca.org.au
7. www.savebabe.com
8. www.voiceless.org.au  
9. www.wspa.org.au

For Support:
1. www.peta2.org
2. www.vegsoc.org.au
3. www.vegiedelights.com.au
4. www.vegcooking.com

How do I know this?
Animals Australia, Why are more and more people becoming vegetarian? http://www.animalsaustralia.org/features/why_vegetarian.php  

Animal Liberation Inc., Cattle, www.animalliberation.org.au/cattle.php  

Animal Liberation Inc., Chickens, www.animalliberation.org.au/chickens.php  

Animal Liberation Inc., Pigs, www.animalliberation.org.au/pigs.php  

Animal Liberation Inc., Sheep, www.animalliberation.org.au/sheep.php  

Australian Bureau of Statistics,
14.41 Livestock and Poultry Slaughtered for Human Consumtion,
http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/
Previousproducts/74C1BEBB6F3542C8CA2570DE00167A86?opendocumentv


Australian Government Department of the Environment and Water Resources—Australian Greenhouse Office,
National Greenhouse Gas inventory analysis of recent trends and greenhouse indicators, 1990 to 2005, http://www.greenhouse.gov.au/inventory/
2005/pubs/trends2005.pdf
 

GoVeg.com, Eating for life, http://www.goveg.org/healthConcerns.asp  

Meat and Livestock Australia, MLA Red meat and nutrition, http://www.mla.com.au/TopicHierarchy/News/Resources/
WellRed/Red+meat+and+nutrition.htm
 

Meat and Livestock Australia, Red meat and nutrition, http://www.mla.com.au/NR/rdonlyres/EF958ED2-3184-46CB-A33C-2AB4CA7830D9/0/Chapter_13.pdf

Meat and Livestock Australia, The role of red meat in healthy Australian diets, http://www.mla.com.au/NR/rdonlyres/B5518223-77AB-4D82-ACE8-9CDB3688DC38/0/SummaryReport2007.pdf

PETA TV—Animal Rights Television, Meet your meat, http://www.petatv.com/

RSPCA Australia, Fair Go for Farm Animals, http://www.rspca.org.au/campaign/fairgo.asp  

SaveBabe.com, Help save Australia’s pigs! http://www.savebabe.com/

Voiceless; the fund for animals, What is Animal Law? http://www.voiceless.org.au/Law/Misc/
What_is_Animal_Law?.html

Discuss Now

Post Comment 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |

RSS Comments
image

nonna 30-Jun-2008

i have obviously missed a very interesting discussion. but i would still like to add some facts and rectify others.

in regards to comments made on 16 march in support of meat as 'mankinds first multivitamin'. the only vitamin missing in the vegan diet is B12. a vegetarian diet however has adequate B12 provided that dairy products are consumed. a vegetarian diet, provided that it is balanced and carefully planned lacks no essential vitamins and minerals required for living.

there are approximately 9 essential amino acids required in our diets. yes, meat contains all these essential amino acids. but you are wrong to state that you cannot consume these as part of a vegetarian diet. all you need to do is match certain sources with others. for example grains are a limited source of the amino acid lysine. a mixed meal of rice and beans will ensure that lysine is consumed. if a persons diet is limiting in one or more of these essential amino acids then proteins cannot be made by the body and human growth and repair will not occur.

i do agree that it is important for belinda to present all sides of the story in a comprehensive argument. but it is just as important for those questioning her arguments not to make up facts to support their own argument.

-----

image

BelindaE 23-Mar-2008

I eagerly recommend reading an opinion piece by actnow member nicoleS, called Go Vego at
http://www.actnow.com.au/Opinion/Go_Vego.aspx

Some very good points!

-----

image

Hirere 22-Mar-2008

I like this article and see where you're comming from. I've eaten meat all my life, I most likely ate a large amount of it too, but after hearing talk and seeing a video on cows being killed in a factory I pretty much stopped buying meat at the super market. It was just cruel to see those animals go through what they do and then seeing a hunk of cooked meat infront of me just didn't feel right.

I've altogether stopped eating beef, I tried to go veggo but that was just too hard and I wasn't well informed on the nutritional side of things. I support and cheer those people who have made that full transition from meat to veggo, I'm secretly jealous of them.

-----

image

BelindaE 20-Mar-2008

Thanks Meli :)

I agree, we only breed the cows to kill them and eat them, so what's the loss if they were never there in the first place?

And again, I think the earth would do a lot better without us. That's not to say I don't like being here...

-----

image

Meli 16-Mar-2008

Great work with this piece Belinda, you know so much about this issue!

[“Imagine cows roaming in the wild.”]

Why not? Less fierce creatures do it all the time. Have a little faith in the cows will ya :P

[We simply wouldn't have a "modern society" without meat.]

Maybe that wouldn’t be such a bad thing…at least we wouldn’t have screwed the world over.

-----